“Nobody Wants This” Cast, Review & Episode Guide. And When is Season 2 Coming?

When Netflix released Nobody Wants This, it quickly became the kind of rom-com that gets everybody talking, binging, and texting about. Created by Erin Foster, this quirky and warm-hearted series brings together Kristen Bell and Adam Brody in a love story that seems almost impossible from the start. She’s a free-spirited podcaster with a knack for shaking things up, and he’s an upstanding rabbi who’s anything but conventional. But as opposites attract, they start a journey that’s as awkward and hilarious as it is heartwarming.

With Nobody Wants This climbing the Netflix charts, the demand for more is clear. Netflix wasted no time in greenlighting Nobody Wants This Season 2, but the big question now is when exactly will it return? Let’s take a look at the cast, episode guide, and what’s in store for the next season.

Nobody Wants This Season 1’s Ending (Spoiler Alert!) and Where Season 2 Will Pick Up?

In the Season 1 finale, Nobody Wants This left us with Noah choosing Joanne, despite their differences. But it’s not the happy ending you might expect. Joanne isn’t ready to convert, and this complicates their future. This cliffhanger leaves plenty of room for Nobody Wants This Season 2 to explore. According to Adam Brody, the second season will look into “what they’re willing to sacrifice to make it work.”

The budding romance between Noah’s brother Sasha and Joanne’s sister Morgan might also take center stage, with more family and faith dilemmas on the horizon. Showrunner Erin Foster, who based Nobody Wants This on her own experience, teases:

“We want to see Joanne and Noah’s world collide even more.”

Erin Foster

When is Nobody Wants This Season 2 Coming Out?

Good news! While Netflix hasn’t announced an official release date for Nobody Wants This Season 2, fans can expect it sometime in 2025, based on the streaming giant’s scheduling hints. 

With the success of Season 1, the next chapter is likely to dig even deeper into the joys and tensions that Joanne and Noah’s relationship stirs up. And with new showrunner Jenni Konner and Bruce Eric Kaplan stepping in, Season 2 promises fresh perspectives.

Will There Be a Nobody Wants This Season 3?

“We have plenty of ideas to keep things going and there’s so much more to say about love, faith, and family.”

Erin Foster on the making of Season 3 of Nobody Wants This

Though a Season 3 hasn’t been confirmed yet, Erin Foster has hinted at more stories to come. So, as long as the fan love keeps streaming in, there’s a good chance Nobody Wants This will stay on our screens.

Meet the Cast of Nobody Wants This

The cast of Nobody Wants This is a mixture of familiar faces and fan favorites, giving it a unique mix of humor and chemistry. Here’s who makes this Netflix series stand out:

• Kristen Bell as Joanne: Bell stars as Joanne, an outspoken podcaster who never thought she’d fall for a rabbi. Known for her roles in The Good Place and Veronica Mars, Bell brings her signature wit and warmth to the role.
• Adam Brody as Rabbi Noah Roklov: Brody plays the rabbi who’s more than just “the good Jewish guy.” Best known for The O.C., he brings an irresistible charm to Noah, a junior rabbi facing family expectations and religious obligations as he falls for Joanne.
• Justine Lupe as Morgan: Lupe, known for her role in Succession, shines as Joanne’s sister and podcast co-host, adding comic relief and a dash of sibling rivalry.
• Timothy Simons as Sasha Roklov: Sasha, Noah’s quirky brother, played by Veep’s Timothy Simons, is the hilarious sidekick who brings his own set of complications to the table, from sibling rivalry to fatherhood.
• Jackie Tohn as Esther: Esther is Sasha’s assertive wife who isn’t thrilled with Joanne’s entrance into Noah’s life. Tohn (GLOW) gives Esther both comedic edge and heart.
• Sherry Cola as Ashley: Ashley, Joanne’s best friend and party host, is no-nonsense and bold. She’s the one who unknowingly sets up the “meet-cute” that sparks Joanne and Noah’s story.
• Tovah Feldshuh as Bina Roklov: Bina is the traditional mother of Noah and Sasha, played by the talented Feldshuh (Lady in the Water), who portrays a Jewish mother’s protective, skeptical love perfectly.
• Stephanie Faracy as Lynn: Lynn, Joanne’s newly divorced mom, is obsessed with the mystical, bringing her own eccentricity to family dynamics.
• Emily Arlook as Rebecca: Rebecca, Noah’s almost-fiancée, is a figure from his past and best friends with Esther, adding complications to Joanne and Noah’s budding romance.

Season 1 Episode Guide — All the Laughs and Awkward Moments

Season 1 of Nobody Wants This plays out in 10 half-hour episodes, which dropped on September 26, 2024, each one bringing its own mix of laughter, romance, and, yes, cringe-worthy moments. Here’s a quick episode guide:

1. Pilot – Joanne and Noah’s meet-cute at a dinner party sparks an unlikely connection.
2. A Shiksa Walks Into a Temple – Joanne sets foot into Noah’s world, stirring up more than a few reactions.
3. Either Aura – Family pressures escalate, testing their budding relationship.
4. Obliterated – An unconventional date leads to both laughter and vulnerability.
5. My Friend Joanne – A test of their bond, with some unexpected teenage opinions.
6. The Ick – Joanne’s family quirks come into focus, revealing hidden family traits.
7. WAGS – A night out at a basketball game softens Esther’s hardened exterior.
8. Rebecca’s Box – Joanne shows growth as she begins to understand Noah’s faith.
9. My Girl Bina – The anticipated meeting with Noah’s mother finally happens, though not without bumps.
10. Bat Mitzvah Crashers – A surprising finale with a “will-they-won’t-they” that leaves viewers wanting more.

The Nobody Wants This episodes each adds to the storyline, combining situational comedy with real emotional stakes. Critics have praised the show for capturing the humor and heart that rom-coms thrive on, with Nobody Wants This Rotten Tomatoes score reflecting its popularity among audiences.

Nobody Wants This Review — Fun, Light, and Full of Nostalgia

Nobody Wants This has been widely praised for its humor and charm, reminiscent of classics like When Harry Met Sally. Critics love Bell and Brody’s chemistry, and fans are drawn to the familiar yet fresh rom-com vibe. Rotten Tomatoes ratings reflect this positive reception, with the show’s “will-they-won’t-they” storyline keeping viewers hooked and nostalgic. From lighthearted banter to real emotional stakes, the series combines humor with heartfelt moments that stay with you long after the credits roll.

While some jokes lean into common stereotypes like the “overbearing Jewish mother” or “eccentric single mom” the show’s cast and witty dialogue make it work. Sasha’s parenting challenges and Noah’s “shiksa” love story keep things unpredictable, adding just the right touch of drama. As Bell puts it,

“The humor and chemistry feel so real. We just clicked.”

Is Nobody Wants This Based on a True Story?

Nobody Wants This isn’t another scripted rom-com it’s loosely inspired by the real-life experiences of creator Erin Foster. Foster, who is no stranger to interfaith relationships, created this series to explore the humor and challenges that arise when different worlds collide. 

While Noah’s character may be fictional, the heart of his relationship with Joanne reflects Foster’s own experiences, lending authenticity to the cultural and familial themes.

Why Watch Nobody Wants This on Netflix?

Nobody Wants This on Netflix is the perfect binge for anyone who loves a light, funny, and heartfelt rom-com. If you’re looking for a show with nostalgia, wit, and just the right amount of drama, this series checks all the boxes. From unforgettable banter to laugh-out-loud moments, Nobody Wants This is here to entertain. And with Season 2 on the way, the fun isn’t over yet.

So, grab your favorite snack, settle in, and get ready to watch Nobody Wants This, the romantic comedy everyone wants to see.